Ask an Attorney a Question for FREE!

No Damage Car Accident - Is Reporting Wise?

by Rose

I was parallel parking and then proceeded to get out of the vehicle. A minute later a man came up to me and said I had "hit" his car and damaged it.

Not only did I not hit him, I did not hear anything or feel any contact with my vehicle. He showed a scratch on his car and said it was my fault and that he actually saw me do it. I again said I did not do this.

He said we could talk "later" about it so I gave him my husbands phone number, as I was sure he would take the license plate info anyway, and possibly try to cause me some problems. He did not ask for my insurance info, and I after I gave him the phone number I felt awkward, that perhaps he was just trying to get my phone number?

He did not call the police then and there, nor his insurance company, that I know of. If he was so certain, do you think he would have called them then and there? Why didn't he? Now, I know I didn't do it, so can he still come after me by making a false claim or calling the police, where I will have to fight this?

What should I do to protect myself? thanks so much, I'd really appreciate some help.


Hum... interesting set of facts. Well, you did have an awkward encounter that is for sure. If you are 100% sure that you did not touch anyone in that parking stall, then you need to protect yourself, but how?

We believe you should call your insurance company. It is kind of silly we know, you are calling to say, I think there is a claim, but you got to remember, you have a duty to report losses within a reasonable time per the terms of your policy. Doing this will endure that your insurance company protect you even in the event of a frivolous lawsuit.

Maybe he did wanted your phone number, but now days it is better to be safe than sorry.

If these people are claiming damage when you did not touch them, then they might claim injuries too (we do not mean to scare you, it is just that there are some people out there looking for a quick buck).

So call your insurance company, tell them what happened and secure coverage. Also tell them that you are 100% sure that you did not cause the accident at all. They will have a duty to believe you unless there is evidence against you.

The only possible evidence will be damages to both vehicles and a police report. The police was not called, and your car has no damage.

You will also benefit from dealing with them directly. It is a weird situation as it is, and you do not want to have a confrontation over this. If they contact you, have them talk to the adjuster. They will have to protect you.

We hope this helps,

Comments for No Damage Car Accident - Is Reporting Wise?

Click here to add your own comments

Mar 06, 2012
Same thing happened to me too
by: mike

Same thing happened to me too, but in my case I was sure that I did not hit other car with my door (maybe only easy touch, because I was opening my door very carefully), and I check visually that there is no even a dust scratch on the other car. So I was not cooperate with him. didn't want to give him my information, and insisted for police.

So I told him to call police, he replayed "I'm police", wrote down my license plate number and left ???

They was so rude, his wife try to stop me in visually exam of their car saying "Don't touch the car"

I don't know what to do now too ??

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Got Questions?.

Please see more answers to recent personal injury and auto accident questions below:

For a Free Review of Your Case
Please Call (866) 878-2432